I’ve combined Amy Johnson Crow’s 52 ancestors in 52 weeks challenge, and Steve Little’s The 2025 AI Genealogy Do-Over, to create a unique 52 AI ancestors in 52 weeks party!
52 AI Ancestors in 52 Weeks: Week 43: Urban
Introduction
What brings a country boy to the city?
At the recent 22nd Annual Genealogy Lock-in co-sponsored by the Ridgewood Public Library and the Genealogical Society of Bergen County (both New Jersey, USA), I told another attendee that I had three separate SMITH lines (oh joy). But Jason M. Smith (1807 – 1890) of New York City is easier than he might have been, because he (and his children) very consistently recorded his place of birth as Vermont.
What prompted this move?
I found an article mentioning that move at NYS Historic Newspapers, a free online newspapers site focused on New York State where you can filter by county.
“His 80th Anniversary,” Richmond County Advance (Staten Island, NY), 17 Dec 1887, page 4, column 2, As found on nyshistoricnewspapers.org
Discussion
Jason Smith moved when he was just 7, so it wasn’t likely to have been his decision. The early move combined with the mention of an apprenticeship makes me wonder if he didn’t lose a parent at a young age. Another possibility is the War of 1812, since he would have turned 7 in 1814. Or perhaps it was economic conditions.
Nonetheless, Jason clearly “made it” in New York. He married twice and raised several children, all of whom seemed to live reasonably comfortable lives.
At 80, he was called “remarkably well preserved for a man of his advanced age.” Whatever the reason for his move, it was apparently a good thing for him.
Figure 1 ChatGPT’s imagining of Vermont to New York City
How AI can help
I can run my theories past AI as a sounding board:
Me to Google: economic conditions in 1814
Google AI’s response: In 1814, the United States experienced severe economic hardship, characterized by high inflation, a trade – crippling British blockade, and a government drowning in debt from the War of 1812.
Or, which theory makes sense? I ran this blog post through Copilot Researcher and asked it.
Me to Copilot Researcher: Using the attached blog post, what do you think of the three options I mentioned for why he moved? Are there reasonable alternatives I didn’t consider?
Copilot Researcher’s response:
Most plausible: Jason’s move at age 7 was likely due to the loss of a parent. In early 1800s New York, fatherless children were often placed in apprenticeships or sent to live with guardians, especially if the family lacked resources. The mention of an apprenticeship strongly supports this scenario. If his father died around 1814, it would explain both the relocation and Jason’s early entry into city life.
Also plausible: Economic hardship during the War of 1812 – especially the trade blockade and inflation – could have pushed the family to seek better opportunities in New York. The timing aligns with widespread financial strain in Vermont, and urban centers offered more support and work options.
Less likely but possible: If Jason’s father served in the War of 1812 and died or was disabled, that could have triggered the move. However, without direct evidence of military service, this remains speculative.
Other ideas: Family migration, remarriage, or urban job prospects may have played a role, but they’re harder to confirm without more records.
I don’t think Jason’s parents had died, but I am not GPS – level confident (I’m not sure I could meet the Genealogical Proof Standard on that supposition). But, AI can be a great sounding board for my theories, and can provide valuable historical context.
Challenge for Readers
Try this two-part “urban exploration” challenge:
- Map It Out – Pick one ancestor who lived in a city or town. Use an online historical map (such as the David Rumsey Map Collection or Sanborn Fire Insurance Maps) to locate their neighborhood. What was nearby – factories, churches, schools, or parks?
- Ask AI – Upload a short description of that ancestor’s life to an AI chat tool and ask:
“What might daily life have been like for someone living here around [year]?”
Compare the AI’s answer to what you find in city directories, newspapers, or censuses. How close is it?
(And for extra credit: see if AI can find connections between your ancestor’s city job and migration patterns of the time!)
AI can suggest possible scenarios, but remember it doesn’t replace checking probate or church records.
Want to Learn More?
- Copilot Researcher: https://www.microsoft.com/en-us/microsoft-365/copilot – overview of Microsoft Copilot features for research and writing
Here are some free, trustworthy resources to look into your city – dwelling ancestors:
- NYS Historic Newspapers: nyshistoricnewspapers.org – already helped in this post!
- Chronicling America: chroniclingamerica.loc.gov – U.S. historic newspapers searchable by city and date.
- City Directories on FamilySearch: familysearch.org/search/catalog – find local residents, occupations, and addresses.
- David Rumsey Map Collection: davidrumsey.com – high – resolution maps for historical city research.
Jason’s story reminds us that even a childhood move two centuries ago can echo through generations – and with a little AI help, we can listen more closely.
Next Week’s Topic: “Rural”
AI Disclosure
This post was created by me with the help of AI tools. While AI helps sort out research, the storytelling and discoveries are my own.
























